Shinnecock Hills at the Center of US Open Setup Debate as Players Brace for Wind and Firm Greens

Shinnecock Hills: The Ultimate Championship Test Returns

As the US Open returns to Shinnecock Hills Golf Club in Southampton, New York, players have used their practice rounds to debate one central question: how firm, fast, and unforgiving should the course be?

Player Reactions

Rory McIlroy called Shinnecock "the best championship test in the country" when conditions align, noting that it demands excellence across every facet of the game — driving, iron play, and short-game composure. Scottie Scheffler highlighted the wind as the defining variable, warning that the direction can shift significantly throughout the day and that gusts of 40+ mph are forecast for Thursday and Friday.

Defending champion JJ Spaun summarized the course's nature succinctly: "You can't win it on day one, but you can definitely lose it."

Setup Concerns

Greens are currently running around 11 on the Stimpmeter during practice — considered close to the ceiling given forecasted wind conditions. The USGA has been watering the greens to prevent a repeat of the 2004 controversy, when the course became widely regarded as unplayable. Brooks Koepka, who won the last Shinnecock edition at 1-over par, noted that conditions are softer than he remembers but acknowledged the USGA could firm things up quickly if needed.

Matt Fitzpatrick, who thrives in demanding conditions, said he would prefer the greens to burn under the Long Island sun — but acknowledged that Shinnecock's topology and persistent wind make daily watering a practical necessity even for members.

Strokeslab Perspective

At Shinnecock, SG: Approach and SG: Around the Green will likely be the decisive metrics — especially the ability to miss greens in recoverable positions and execute creative up-and-downs from tricky runoff areas.